Head to head
State Farm vs Allstate in Florida
Updated August 2026
State Farm and Allstate are the two classic agent-network insurers: both built their brands on local offices with the company's name on the door. The similarity mostly ends there. State Farm is a mutual company — owned by its policyholders, with no stock ticker — and is the largest auto insurer in the United States. Allstate is publicly traded, answers to shareholders, and has added a direct online channel alongside its captive agents.
Ownership and distribution shape how each company behaves, but they don't set your price. Florida rates come out of dozens of rating factors run through each insurer's own formula, and the same driver can see very different numbers from these two. This page lays out the structural differences so those numbers make sense — then the quotes decide.
| State Farm | Allstate | |
|---|---|---|
| Founded | 1922 | 1931 |
| Ownership | Mutual company — owned by its policyholders | Publicly traded (NYSE: ALL) |
| AM Best rating | A++ (Superior) | A+ (Superior) |
| How it sells | Captive/exclusive State Farm agents | Captive Allstate agents plus a direct online/phone channel |
| Telematics program | Drive Safe & Save | Drivewise, plus Milewise pay-per-mile in select states |
| SR-22 / non-standard appetite | Generally does not pursue new SR-22-heavy non-standard business | Primarily a standard-market writer; filing availability depends on your record — ask when quoting |
| Eligibility notes | Open to the general public; the largest US auto insurer | Open to the general public |
Source: Company disclosures and AM Best public ratings
The agent model, two ways
Both companies sell through captive agents — offices that represent only their own brand, unlike independent agencies that quote many carriers. A State Farm agent sells State Farm; an Allstate agent sells Allstate. The difference is what sits around the agent: Allstate also runs a direct channel, so you can buy and manage a policy online without an office involved, while State Farm keeps the agent at the center of the relationship.
For Florida drivers the choice is really about how you want to be served. If you want one local office handling auto, home and umbrella together, both deliver that. If you want the option of skipping the office entirely, Allstate's structure allows it and State Farm's mostly doesn't.
Mutual vs shareholder-owned — does it matter to you?
State Farm's mutual structure means the company is owned by the people it insures; there are no outside shareholders. Allstate's public structure means it raises capital in the markets and reports to investors every quarter. These are genuinely different ways to run an insurer, and people argue sincerely about which produces better long-term behavior.
What neither structure does is predict your premium. Both companies file rates with Florida's regulator and price on the same kinds of factors — driving record, vehicle, location, coverage choices. A mutual can quote you high and a public company low, or the reverse. Treat ownership as background, not as a buying signal.
Which kinds of drivers each tends to fit
State Farm tends to fit drivers with clean or near-clean records who want a long-running relationship with one office — families bundling auto and home, drivers who'd rather call a person than open an app. It is generally not the door for SR-22-heavy profiles, since it doesn't pursue new non-standard business. Allstate tends to fit drivers who want the agent-plus-digital mix, and — where Milewise is available — low-mileage drivers drawn to pay-per-mile pricing.
In Florida, where full coverage typically runs about $2,786–$2,953 a year statewide (MoneyGeek/Insure.com) and the regulator reported the five largest auto insurer groups filing average decreases of roughly 8% for 2026, the spread between two quotes is worth chasing. Structure tells you the experience; your quote decides the carrier.
Frequently asked questions
Is State Farm or Allstate cheaper in Florida?+
Neither is categorically cheaper. Each runs its own rating formula, so the same Florida driver can get meaningfully different numbers from the two. With statewide full coverage typically around $2,786–$2,953 a year (MoneyGeek/Insure.com), that spread is worth real money — get both quotes on identical coverage and let them compete.
Will State Farm file an SR-22 in Florida?+
State Farm generally does not pursue new SR-22-heavy non-standard business, so drivers who need a filing usually end up quoting carriers with real appetite for it — Progressive and the non-standard specialists among them. If you already hold a State Farm policy, ask your agent what your specific situation allows.
What's the difference between a mutual and a publicly traded insurer?+
A mutual like State Farm is owned by its policyholders and has no stock; a public company like Allstate is owned by shareholders and trades on an exchange. It changes who the company answers to, not how your claim is handled or what you'll be quoted — both are regulated the same way in Florida.
Do both offer telematics in Florida?+
Both run usage-based programs — Drive Safe & Save at State Farm, Drivewise at Allstate, with Allstate's Milewise pay-per-mile product limited to select states. Program availability and terms shift, so confirm what's currently offered in Florida when you quote, and remember these programs reward the driving you actually do.
ShowMyRates is an independent comparison service, not affiliated with either company. Marks belong to their owners; details reflect public disclosures and can change. This page compares product structure — the only way to compare prices is a quote for your own profile.
State Farm or Allstate? Your quote decides
Structure narrows the choice — the price for your exact profile settles it. Free, about 2 minutes.
See my rates